By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
After a legal battle that began in 2013, Starbucks prevailed against Coffee Rocks before the General Court of the European Union. The Court held that the similarities between the figurative marks may harm Starbucks' reputation, even without a direct likelihood of confusion. Well-known marks therefore enjoy broader protection.
The judgment of the General Court of the European Union (T-398/16 - Starbucks v EUIPO - Nersesyan (COFFEE ROCKS)) marks the end of a long legal battle that began in 2013. Coffee Rocks has come off worse.
According to the Board of Appeal, there was no likelihood of confusion between the Starbucks figurative marks and the Coffee Rocks figurative mark, because the distinctive and dominant elements differ. In its appeal, Starbucks argued that the Board of Appeal had erred and had wrongly failed to assess the reputation of the earlier mark.
The General Court did not agree with the Board of Appeal either. The fact that the marks are sufficiently different to rule out a likelihood of confusion does not mean that the reputation and renown of the earlier well-known mark are not being infringed. The General Court found that the marks are sufficiently similar for this purpose and highlighted their visual similarities. The marks are characterised by the same overall appearance. Both are round emblems consisting of two parts: a figure in the centre and a ring around it with two white lines. The text is also found in the same position, separated by two stars and two musical notes respectively. In addition, the colour combinations and the font are the same. Finally, the word "coffee" appears in both marks. All these points of similarity should have led the Board of Appeal to assess whether the later mark takes advantage of the reputation of the earlier mark.
The General Court's criticism of the EUIPO therefore concerns the fact that the EUIPO assessed the concept of "similarity between the marks" only with a view to a possible likelihood of confusion within the meaning of Article 8(1) EUTMR, whereas "similarity between the marks" within the meaning of Article 8(5) EUTMR need not lead to a likelihood of confusion. It is sufficient if the earlier well-known mark is called to mind by consumers when they see the later mark, or if a 'link' between the two marks is established. This does justice to the principle that well-known marks enjoy a broader scope of protection than marks that are not well known.