Fraud Blocker Common knowledge in plant breeders' rights - Hortis Legal

Common knowledge and nullity in plant breeders' rights

By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·

In its Strong Energy/Strong Strike judgment of 3 October 2023, the Court of Appeal of The Hague clarified the concept of 'common knowledge' in plant breeders' rights. It is not registration in the unofficial KAVB register alone, but additional facts and circumstances, that make a variety a matter of common knowledge. The Court also held that Dutch legislation that does not give retroactive effect to declarations of nullity of plant breeders' rights is contrary to the UPOV Convention.

Common knowledge and nullity in plant breeders' rights

The concept of 'common knowledge' in plant breeders' rights

One of the requirements for a valid plant breeders' right is that, on the filing date, the candidate variety is clearly distinguishable from any other variety whose existence is a matter of common knowledge. As to what is meant by common knowledge of a variety, plant breeders' rights legislation (international, European and national) gives two examples: (i) the existence of plant variety protection, or (ii) entry of a variety in an official register of varieties. The UPOV Technical Guideline TG/1/3 mentions additional facts and circumstances that may give rise to common knowledge: (iii) commercialisation of propagating or harvested material of the variety, or the publication of a detailed description, and (iv) the availability of living material of the variety in publicly accessible plant collections.

In a judgment of 3 October 2023, the Court of Appeal of The Hague considered the concept of 'common knowledge' in plant breeders' rights in detail. In short, the Court held that the tulip variety Strong Energy was a variety of common knowledge on 13 June 2013, when HBM filed an application for the grant of plant breeders' rights for Strong Strike. According to the District Court and the Court of Appeal, the fact that Strong Energy was entered in the KAVB register, which does not as yet have the status of an 'official register of varieties', was not decisive for establishing common knowledge. Other factors led to common knowledge, namely:

  • Publication of the variety in a trade journal;
  • Public visibility on inspection days;
  • Inclusion in the KAVB reference collection;
  • The large membership of the KAVB;
  • Online accessibility of the KAVB register;
  • Inclusion in the Plantscope database (another register);
  • Public accessibility of the KAVB trial garden.

The District Court and the Court of Appeal also found that common knowledge does not require that the earlier variety Strong Energy was actually known, but merely that it could have been. It is therefore a question of the degree of probability that a variety is known. Nor does the variety need to be known everywhere in the world, but only in the part of the world where this is relevant. This brings the concept close to 'disclosure' in design law, where what matters is whether the design could reasonably have become known to the circles specialised in the sector concerned.

Nullity of plant breeders' rights ex tunc or ex nunc?

A second question answered by the Court was whether a declaration of nullity of a plant breeders' right should have retroactive effect to the date on which the right was originally granted (ex tunc). Under Articles 75(4) and 77(2) of the Dutch Seeds and Planting Materials Act 2005 (Zaaizaad- en plantgoedwet 2005), this is not the case and the plant breeders' right would be nullified only as from the date of the claim for nullity (ex nunc). The Court held, however, that this national legislation is contrary to Article 21 of the UPOV Convention, which leaves no room for a decision declaring a plant breeders' right null and void without retroactive effect. A reprimand for the national legislature, which has therefore incorrectly implemented this provision of the UPOV Convention.

Questions?

Feel free to contact us

More news