By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
In this article, we take a stroll through the garden of trade marks and variety names in the plant sector. The distinction between the two is important for safeguarding both the quality and the origin of plants. The article explains how trade marks help consumers choose, while variety names allow anyone to identify specific plant varieties.
Trade marks are widely used in the plant sector, in particular to guarantee the origin and quality of certain plants. This may be a company's trade mark for one specific plant variety, a trade mark promoting a series of different plants, or even a collective quality mark intended to guarantee the quality of plants from different companies. Although the reputation of a trade mark can add a lot of value to a business, a trade mark essentially exists not for the trade mark owner but for the consumer. The main function of a trade mark is to enable consumers to distinguish certain goods (or services) from those of competing businesses. If, for example, trade mark X is used for plants that are resistant to certain viruses, while trade mark Y does not have this characteristic, consumers must be able to distinguish sufficiently between the two marks on their first and subsequent purchases. A trade mark also has, among other things, an advertising, quality, investment and communication function.
Variety denominations legally belong to a different category of names. A variety denomination is simply the name of a plant variety and therefore a generic designation. In principle, anyone must be free to use such a generic designation to identify or refer to a particular plant variety by name. It may happen, however, that a particular variety denomination has acquired a reputation, for example because the specific variety has a unique characteristic, such as winter hardiness. Third parties sometimes take unfair advantage of the reputation of the variety denomination by using it for a plant variety that is not winter-hardy at all, or that is even of inferior quality. This 'riding on the coat-tails' of the reputation, to the detriment of the plant breeders' rights holder, is something the rights holder can take legal action against. Plant breeders' rights legislation obliges everyone to use the correct variety denomination for plant material traded in the course of trade. Variety A may therefore not be traded under the registered variety denomination of variety B, and vice versa. This applies not only for the duration of the plant breeders' right, but also afterwards. Which makes sense, because generic designations are general in nature and do not in themselves qualify as intellectual property rights.
It is therefore not unusual for a protected variety to be traded under a commercial brand name in addition to its registered variety denomination. Both the variety denomination and the commercial name are communicated in the course of trade. In practice, the brand name will take a more prominent place in marketing, owing to its advertising and communication function, among other things, whereas the variety denomination serves only to identify a specific variety and is not always noticed by the average consumer. To the extent that a variety denomination enjoys any protection, it cannot be compared with the far-reaching and perpetual exclusive rights that a trade mark owner enjoys. Whereas plant breeders' rights legislation only imposes a general obligation on everyone (including the rights holder) to use the correct variety denomination, a trade mark gives its owner the exclusive right to prohibit any third party from using a sign in the course of trade, even where that sign is similar to the protected mark, is used for similar goods (including other plant varieties) and causes confusion.
Finally, it should be noted that trade mark authorities are becoming increasingly alert to the existence of earlier variety denominations. For example, the new EU Trade Mark Regulation provides that signs will be refused if they consist of, or reproduce in their essential elements, an earlier plant variety denomination and relate to plant varieties of the same or closely related species (Article 7(1)(m) EUTMR). Conversely, a proposed variety denomination is considered unsuitable if an earlier right already exists in that denomination, such as an earlier trade mark right (Article 63(3)(a) of the Community Plant Variety Rights Regulation). The difference is that a trade mark application will in that case be refused ex officio (the trade mark office itself consults various variety registers), whereas in practice a proposed variety denomination is only refused if the holder of an earlier right objects. Such an availability check is certainly not a bad thing for a proposed variety denomination, but for plant breeders' rights holders it is of course much better to trade their protected varieties under registered brand names. For more information or advice on this, please feel free to contact us.