Fraud Blocker Refiling a trade mark: bad faith? - Hortis Legal

Refiling a trade mark to avoid the use requirement? That may be bad faith

By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·

Can you simply refile a trade mark you already own? Usually, yes. But if you do so to avoid having to prove that you genuinely use the mark, your new registration may be declared invalid. That is clear from a judgment of the General Court of the European Union of 21 October 2026 in the WATERDROP case (T-541/25).

Refiling a trade mark to avoid the use requirement? That may be bad faith

A trade mark must be used

A trade mark registration gives you an exclusive right, but it comes with an obligation. If you own an EU trade mark, you must put it to genuine use within five years of registration. This is called "genuine use". If you do not, someone else can have your trade mark revoked. You will also no longer be able to rely on the mark effectively against a competitor: in opposition or infringement proceedings, the other party can require you to prove that use.

During the first five years after registration, this is not yet required. That period is known as the grace period. During it, you do not have to prove anything.

And therein lies the temptation. If you refile a trade mark (a "repeat filing"), the new registration gets a new five-year grace period. This seems to make it possible to keep pushing the use requirement further into the future. Internationally, this is also known as "evergreening".

What did the General Court decide?

The General Court made clear at the outset that refiling an identical or virtually identical trade mark is not automatically in bad faith. There may be good reasons for doing so, such as a redesigned logo or a product that has genuinely been added.

In this case, however, it went wrong. The General Court found that the trade mark owner had acted in bad faith. That applied to the goods for which the new mark overlapped exactly with the old registrations. For those goods, the new registration is therefore invalid.

What did the General Court look at?

Bad faith concerns the intention of the applicant. The court infers that intention from the circumstances. The General Court referred, among other things, to:

The timeline and the similarities. The old and new registrations were very similar and the sequence of filings pointed to a pattern.
Use of the new mark in oppositions. The trade mark owner relied on the new mark against others, precisely where it could not yet be asked to prove use of that mark.
No credible business reason. The trade mark owner could not convincingly explain why the repeat filing was commercially necessary.
Indications that the use requirement was being circumvented. Taken together, everything pointed to the new grace period being used to avoid having to prove genuine use.
Fine words are not enough

The trade mark owner argued that the repeat filing was intended to "consolidate" its trade mark portfolio, modernise it and make it administratively simpler. The General Court found this insufficient, because there was no evidence that this was the real reason. Such an explanation must be backed up with documents.

Nor did the argument that the trade mark owner might well have been able to prove use of its earlier marks help. If the purpose of the repeat filing was improper, that does not change the bad faith.

Part of an established line

The judgment does not stand alone. In 2021, the General Court had already held that toy manufacturer Hasbro had partly refiled the MONOPOLY trade mark in bad faith (T-663/19). There too, the aim was to avoid having to prove genuine use. The WATERDROP judgment confirms that line and shows which facts can be decisive.

Is this the final word?

Not quite. An appeal against the judgment lies to the Court of Justice, but only on points of law. Moreover, in cases that started before the EUIPO Boards of Appeal, the Court of Justice will only hear such an appeal if it raises an issue that is significant with respect to the unity, consistency or development of EU law.

Are you a trade mark owner?

Before any repeat filing, record why you are refiling. A good reason is, for example, a genuinely changed logo or word mark, or new goods or services that you will actually offer.
Avoid the new mark covering exactly the same goods as the old one without good reason.
Consider surrendering old registrations if the new mark genuinely replaces them.
Keep evidence of use of all your trade marks. That remains the best protection.

Are you being challenged on the basis of a (re)filed trade mark?

Map out the trade mark owner's complete filing history: which marks, when, and for which goods.
Check whether the new mark is being used in oppositions or enforcement proceedings precisely when the old marks are vulnerable to a non-use defence.
An application for a declaration of invalidity on grounds of bad faith can then be a powerful counter-weapon.
Need help?

Hortis Legal advises on building and maintaining trade mark portfolios and on proceedings before the BOIP and the EUIPO. Are you unsure whether a repeat filing is wise, or are you faced with a trade mark that looks suspiciously like an earlier registration? Feel free to contact us.

Source: Judgment of the General Court of the EU of 21 October 2026, Case T-541/25 (WATERDROP), eur-lex.europa.eu.

Questions?

Feel free to contact us

More news