Fraud Blocker No shape mark for new Coca-Cola bottle - Hortis Legal

No shape mark for new Coca-Cola bottle

By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·

The European trade mark office has definitively refused the modern Coca-Cola bottle as a shape mark, finding that it lacks distinctive character on the European soft drinks market. Despite a market survey in ten EU countries showing that consumers associated the bottle shape with Coca-Cola, the General Court found this evidence insufficient for registration, since it was not shown that the bottle had acquired distinctiveness as a trade mark throughout the EU.

No shape mark for new Coca-Cola bottle
No shape mark for new Coca-Cola bottle

It is well known that the European trade mark office is strict when assessing potential shape marks. Even the Coca-Cola bottle has now been definitively refused, after proceedings that went all the way to the General Court of the European Union (judgment of 24 February 2016, T-411/14).

The shape mark (see photo above) was refused because it lacks distinctive character and therefore cannot function as a trade mark. The bottle was found not to stand out from other soft drink bottles on the European market. Coca-Cola registered the old, ribbed bottle as a shape mark back in 1952 and wanted to achieve the same with the modern version.

If a trade mark application is refused for lack of distinctiveness, a market survey can show that the mark has acquired distinctiveness through use. If a potential mark has acquired sufficient distinctiveness and consumers therefore recognise it as a trade mark, the application can still be accepted and registered.

Coca-Cola carried out a market survey in ten member states of the European Union, showing that consumers did indeed recognise the shape as a distinctive sign of Coca-Cola, as many as 79% in Spain. According to the General Court, however, this was not enough, because the survey could not show that the bottle had acquired distinctiveness throughout the entire European Union.

Had Coca-Cola also carried out the market survey in the other seventeen EU member states (the EU had 27 member states when the application was filed), the bottle would very likely have been registered as a shape mark.

More news