By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
The Court of Appeal of The Hague declared the shape mark for the Capri-Sun stand-up pouch invalid, and the Dutch Supreme Court confirmed this in 2019. The functional trapezium shape is not eligible for trade mark protection, and there was no slavish imitation by Riha.
The shape mark for the Capri-Sun stand-up pouch is invalid. That was the ruling of the Court of Appeal of The Hague, which the Dutch Supreme Court upheld on 28 June 2019. The shape of the pouch is functional (technical) in nature and therefore cannot be protected as a trade mark. The so-called trapezium shape is not a creative choice, but follows from its function: a drinks container that can stand upright during use to prevent spills.
Nor was there any slavish imitation by Riha. Slavish imitation is a Dutch doctrine under the law of tort, separate from trade mark law. Where the shape of the pouch might cause confusion, that confusion cannot be avoided without impairing the soundness and usability of the stand-up pouches. Riha therefore did not have to change the shape.
Source: Dutch Supreme Court, 28 June 2019, NJ 2019/332 (Capri Sun/Riha).