By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
This article discusses the differences between plant breeders' rights and patent law in the Netherlands. Patent law protects human-made inventions, such as new technologies, which can be described in detail and whose novelty is lost if they are made public before the application. Plant breeders' rights, by contrast, protect new plant varieties, which are less predictable and whose novelty is lost only if the variety is made available for commercial purposes.
Plant breeders' rights versus patent law: what are the differences?
In the Netherlands, plant breeders' rights protect new plant varieties, somewhat similar to the way a patent protects inventions. But there are also important differences between these two forms of protection.
A patent protects an invention that has been developed entirely by humans. Think, for example, of a new device or technology. Such an invention can be described precisely and reproduced in the same way. Because it is created entirely by human action, an invention can also easily be kept secret until the patent application is filed.
Plant breeders' rights work differently. This right protects a plant variety which, although influenced by humans, is at its core still a natural product. Plant varieties cannot always be described precisely and may sometimes develop differently than expected. That makes them less predictable than industrial inventions.
The difference in 'novelty'
In plant breeders' rights, 'novelty' is about whether the plant variety has been sold or otherwise made available, by or with the consent of the breeder, for the purposes of exploiting the variety before the filing date. If the variety is given to others without a profit motive, this does not affect its novelty. The problem with novelty therefore only arises once plants or parts of plants have become accessible to everyone. In patent law this is different: there, the novelty of an invention is lost as soon as the invention has been made public before the filing date.
In addition, breeders often have to experiment openly to develop a new plant variety, which means their work is less easy to keep secret. This is why plant breeders' rights require a different concept of 'novelty' from patents.
Curious to learn more about the differences and how they work in practice? Keep following our articles for a deeper dive into the world of plant breeding and plant breeders' rights.