By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
From flip to flop, we dive from the first electronic memory steps of 1919, with Eccles and Jordan's surprising circuit, to the present day, where computers can even play the muse, thanks to AIVA from Aiva Technologies. This digital Beethoven has turned the music world upside down and has been recognised by SACEM, but it is still in a legal grey area: is an AI a real composer or not?
Computers can do more and more and are indispensable in our modern society. Only a century ago, in 1919, the invention of the flip-flop laid the foundation for electronic digital memory. While experimenting with vacuum tubes used in radio engineering, Eccles and Jordan discovered a circuit with an interesting property: memory. Normally, the output signal of a circuit changes depending on the input signal, but this 'flip-flop' was different. It had two inputs and two possible stable states. A short pulse on one input put the circuit in 'state 0' ('flip'), and only a pulse on the other input could return it to 'state 1' ('flop'). In this way, the flip-flop 'remembered' the number 0 or 1, laying the foundation for digital memory. Today, millions of flip-flops are combined on chips at the heart of every modern computer.
Less than 100 years later, in 2016, the company Aiva Technologies developed an artificial intelligence called AIVA (Artificial Intelligence Virtual Artist), which enables computers to compose artistic musical works. By reading a large collection of existing works of classical music (written by human composers such as Bach, Beethoven and Mozart), AIVA's algorithm is able to discover patterns in music and compose musical works on that basis.
SACEM, the French copyright collecting society, has officially recognised AIVA as a composer. This raises all kinds of legal complications, such as whether such composers are also copyright holders, like human composers. For now, this does not appear to be the case. Animals, for example, cannot be copyright holders either. According to the US court, the world-famous Indonesian macaque that played with a camera and took a selfie was not regarded as a copyright holder. A speed camera that takes photos at the side of the road on its own is not a photographer within the meaning of copyright law either. The same reasoning can be applied to 'virtual artists' such as AIVA.
Even so, legislators today are grappling with the developments that technology is bringing about, particularly in our digital world. YouTube, for example, is one of the largest providers of music and video, yet pays relatively little or nothing to copyright holders. When protected works are uploaded to YouTube without permission, it is important for liability purposes to determine whether YouTube is merely a passive 'host' or an active party communicating the works to the public. This question has not yet been answered, so the legal position remains unclear. Another complication arises with 'news aggregators': web applications that automatically take headlines from news sites and link to them. Examples include Google News, news items on Facebook, Snapchat, and so on.
A At the time, the European Commission proposed a directive on copyright in the Digital Single Market to tackle this problem. That directive gives press publishers exclusive rights to the digital use of their press publications, but this does not cover hyperlinking to news items or the use of individual words or very short extracts of press publications. It is precisely these exceptions that lie at the heart of the problem with news aggregators, which is why many felt the directive did not solve the problem. The proposal has since been adopted as Directive (EU) 2019/790 (the DSM Directive) and has been part of Dutch law since 7 June 2021. With the rise of generative AI, press publishers' rights have taken on new significance; read our blog on AI chatbots and press publishers' rights.
Technological developments make our world easier, but at the same time much more complicated. We are constantly challenged to define what a creation is and to strike the right balance between protection and freedoms.