Fraud Blocker Compulsory licence - Hortis Legal

Compulsory licence

By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·

In March 2018, the CPVO refused an application, filed in 2017, for a compulsory licence for the blackcurrant variety 'Ben Starav', because it could not be shown that the public interest was harmed. This decision followed despite the argument that compulsory licences may be granted to protect health or to promote the marketing of material with certain characteristics. The CPVO stressed that the advantages of 'Ben Starav' were not unique and that the refusal would not have harmful health effects in the EU, pointing to the availability of alternative varieties for fruit juice production.

Compulsory licence

On 16 March 2017, the CPVO received an application for the grant of a compulsory licence for the first time. The CPVO only grants compulsory licences on grounds of public interest and after consulting the Administrative Council.

The CPVO refused the application for the compulsory licence because it could not establish that the public interest was harmed. The application for a compulsory licence had been filed for the blackcurrant variety 'Ben Starav'.

What counts as a public interest?

Grounds of public interest may include the protection of human, animal or plant life or health, the need to supply the market with material offering specific features, or the need to maintain the incentive for the continued breeding of improved varieties. After hearing the opinion of the Administrative Council, the CPVO refused to grant a compulsory licence in its decision of 28 March 2018. According to the CPVO, the applicant for the compulsory licence had not provided sufficient evidence of the public interest ground in support of its request.

No right to a licence

While a Community plant variety right is in force, its holder has certain exclusive rights to market the variety. There is therefore a temporary monopoly (for 25 or 30 years) to commercialise the variety. The holder can choose whether or not to grant licences. The mere argument that the holder does not want to grant a licence, or that the holder does not commercialise the variety at all, is not sufficient to obtain a compulsory licence. A compulsory licence is granted only on grounds of public interest.

In its decision, the CPVO concluded that the applicant for the compulsory licence must prove that there is a public interest justifying the grant of a compulsory licence, and that it is not merely a licence the applicant wants in order to serve its own personal and commercial interests.

Why 'Ben Starav' is not unique

The CPVO further stated that any benefits of blackcurrants in general for public health cannot be relevant, and that it cannot be inferred from the fact that 'Ben Starav' is not used for the production of not-from-concentrate fruit juices (juices made directly from fresh fruit and vegetables by mechanical processing and pressing) that the absence of a compulsory licence for 'Ben Starav' will have harmful consequences for public health in the EU.

The CPVO explained that 'Ben Starav' is not unique, in the sense that none of the characteristics put forward by the applicant (a consistently high yield of good-quality fruit, a harvest season that does not clash with other cultivars, ripeness at harvest, good juice quality, bud break in many types of winter, a good compositional analysis and excellent colour) can be regarded as 'unique' to that variety; rather, these characteristics are shared by all good fruit-bearing plants intended for juice pressing. In this respect, the CPVO concluded that it suffices to note that twelve other blackcurrant varieties are used for the production of 'Ribena'. Ribena is a brand of British origin of still and carbonated soft drinks and fruit drink concentrate based on blackcurrants.

Questions?

Feel free to contact us

More news