By Rachaad Farzand Ali ·
In opposition case No B 1958266, the Opposition Division of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) considered whether there was a likelihood of confusion between the figurative marks "CHAMPION" and "CHEMPIOIL". Both marks were used in the same territory for the same product, namely engine oil. A clear case of trade mark infringement, or not?
In opposition case No B 1958266, the Opposition Division of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) considered whether there was a likelihood of confusion between the figurative marks "CHAMPION" and "CHEMPIOIL". Both marks were used for exactly the same goods, namely engine oil. The Opposition Division initially held that there was a likelihood of confusion on the part of the relevant public. An important consideration for this finding was the overall similarity resulting from the aural and visual similarity between the two signs. On appeal, however, the Board of Appeal (BoA) held that there was no likelihood of confusion between "CHAMPION" and "CHEMPIOIL". The General Court and, on further appeal, the Court of Justice upheld that decision. The reason why, according to the Board of Appeal and the courts, there is no likelihood of confusion despite the high degree of visual and aural similarity lies in the principle of neutralisation. In trade mark law, the concept of "neutralisation" refers to a situation in which two marks are so clearly different conceptually that their visual and aural similarities become less relevant, or even irrelevant, to the assessment of the likelihood of confusion. In the earlier Picasso/Picaro judgment (C-361/04 P), the Court of Justice held that, as a result of the significant conceptual difference, the average consumer will not perceive the marks as similar visually or aurally either.